After Aquila lectured the council about ethics, he then asked does this have an appearance of a conflict of interest and then answered his own question with the word absolutely. Office of the City Attorney 1001 W. Center St. Manteca, CA 95337 (209) 456-8000. Development Services Office 1215 W. Center St., Suite 201 Manteca, CA 95337 (209) 456-8000. Afterwards, Councilman Jose Nuno said he liked the idea of having dual comment periods with two conditions. Singhs alleged conflict according to Aquila determined weeks ago to not being a conflict under state law by attorneys for both the City of Manteca and San Joaquin Council of Governments stems from the councils involvement in moving the Highway 99/120-Austin Road upgraded project forward. Morowit indicated that it didnt matter that other communities only have one comment period as he didnt mind if Manteca was a trail blazer.. This will provide transparency and accountability ensuring all people feel their voices are heard. Share & Bookmark, Press Enter to show all options, press Tab go to next option, Legal Aid Services and Welfare Rights Organizations, San Joaquin County Bar Association website, Superior Court of California - County of San Joaquin website, Superior Court of California - County of San Joaquin Website. * Live TV from 100+ channels. For more information on an agenda item or the agenda process, please contact the City Clerks Office at 456-8017. - 500 character limitEmail [emailprotected] - Received no later than two hours prior to the meeting and limited to 250 words to be read into the record. One audience member that continued to be augmentative was nudged toward the door by an officer. Manteca, California 95337, Website Design by Granicus - Connecting People and Government. Cantu, who repeatedly had told audience members to stop with outbursts and to show decorum or else he would have them removed, at one point gaveled the meeting into a recess. To contact Dennis Wyatt, email dwyatt@mantecabulletin.com, Its the 6,000-pund Tesla X in the room: California vehicle fees based on weight, Turlock, Denair school districts address campus security after recent incidents, City seeks public input on federally-funded housing, homeless services plan, East Unions come back falls short at Pierce, BOYS VOLLEYBALL: Manteca sweeps Lodi in season opener, ATHLETE OF THE WEEK: Luke Crivello, Ripon Christian basketball, EU girls travel to Arbuckle tonight for NorCal opener; RC hosts Madera South. Email:Send Email. The wording that Aquila used, his repeated references to Singhs wife and the fact Aquila publicly announced the address repeatedly of the house where Singh and his family lived prompted Breitenbucher to note first speakers talk about ethics and then they undercut them with an attack not based on facts. It takes place at 6 p.m. at the University Waterfront Hotel in Stockton. That prompted Breitenbucher to tell Raff he had listened to him speak and it was Raffs turn to listen to him. The next scheduled City Council meeting is October 19, 2021, at 7:00 p.m. 588 were here. He suggested at the time that perhaps the council might want to look at moving public comments to the end of the meeting with the move to an earlier start time. No, the City Attorney is legally prohibited from representing individuals or entities in private legal matters. City Council Meeting 07:00 PM Mar 21 City Council Meeting 06:00 PM Apr 04 City Council Meeting 06:00 PM MORE EVENTS NEWS Severe Weather Alerts SantaRun Maps Available Here General Plan Update and Recirculated Draft Program EIR More News DISCOVER MANTECA Manteca Business Licenses 46 Number of Business Licenses Issued Council meeting agendas are posted at City Hall and online the Thursday prior to a council meeting. You are now exiting the Manteca, CA website. Meeting Date Meeting Time Meeting Location Meeting Details Supplementals Agenda Minutes Video eComment; CITY COUNCIL: 2/21/2023: 7:00 PM: Council Chambers: Meeting details: Not available: Agenda: Not available: Not available: Not available: Planning Commission: 2/16/2023: 6:00 PM: Council Chambers: Meeting details: Not available: Agenda: Not . California shouldnt be crowing, nor should Texas be eating crow, Its nuts to have a cow over milk when the real threat is myopic green narratives pitched in silos, What does $237,000 in tax dollars + $31,000 in staff time buy Manteca? Contact the City Council. Manteca Police needed to restore decorum in the City Council chambers. Instead it was what might best be called a gawdy Christmas suit jacket. The official agenda is posted outside of City Hall, at the Lathrop Post Office, Lathrop Community Center and at the Fire Station. Any materials submitted to the Council after distribution of the agenda packet will be available for public review in the City Clerks Office during normal business hours and will be available for review at the City Council meeting. Name Manteca City Council Suggest Edit Address 1001 West Center Street Manteca , California , 95337 Phone 209-456-8000 Hours Mon-Thu 7:30 AM-5:30 PM; Fri 8:00 AM-5:00 PM Public Meeting: 2023-2031 Housing Element Update. Exceptions: The time limit may be extended by the Mayor, or through a majority vote of the City Council, as deemed necessary. Watch live meetings, search for agenda items and view past meetings online. Claim forms are available online or from the Employee Services and Engagement Department. Jose and his wife, Gabriela, moved to Manteca; her home town, after they were married in 2006 where they are raising their two children. Please enable JavaScript in your browser for a better user experience. Councilman Dave Breitenbucher got in a heated exchange with an audience member over the citys proposed homeless navigation center and slammed a speaker for going beyond the boundaries of common decency. Office of the City Attorney Resident Dennis Raff decried a Manteca where the homeless dying in the streets is the new norm and where homeless are creating hundreds of dollars in property losses for businesses as they try to access water in fire sprinkler systems. Email:Send Email. Phone:(209) 456-8017 Rotary International, Manteca, 2015 current. City of Manteca. The concern about moving to an earlier start time impacting the ability of some to address the council on non-agenda issues was first brought up two weeks ago by Halford. California shouldnt be crowing, nor should Texas be eating crow, Its nuts to have a cow over milk when the real threat is myopic green narratives pitched in silos, What does $237,000 in tax dollars + $31,000 in staff time buy Manteca? Mayoral candidate Lei Ann Larson demanded an independent investigation of one of her opponents, Gary Singh. Copies of the Statement of Economic Interests filed by the above elected officers may be obtained by visiting the offices of the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) or the City Clerk. in Psychology, Modesto Junior College, Associates Degree, Behavioral and Social Sciences. Manteca, CA 95337, Phone: (209) 456-8017 Monday - Thursday . Published: Dec 21, 2022, 3:32 AM Hanukkah for the for the first time in history was officially recognized at a Manteca City Council meeting with the lighting of the menorah. Tuesday's City Council meeting started with the first four speakers including Larson and her advisor Frank Aquila arguing Singh had a conflict. The Statements of Economic Interests for some state and local government agency elected officers may be available in electronic format on the FPPCs website. Councilman Mike Morowit and City Attorney Dave Nefouse provided the invocation. Manteca provides both residents and businesses with many organic waste options. At the end of the meeting when Breitenbucher sought to clear up a point that the navigation center will not be a regional center, and that Assemblyman Heath Flora whose text has been used to claim that it is was actually referring to two homeless projects with one in Manteca and the other in Modesto and that they would help the region, Raff kept interrupting him. By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism. The City of Manteca was the focus of several reports in local media that were critical of the mayor, city council, and the city manager's actions, which resulted in the loss of several city executives. To assist you in meeting those requirements, the City has prepared a claim form for your use. I hereby certify that the agenda for the above stated meeting was posted at a location accessible to members of the public at City Hall, 1001 W. Center Street, Manteca, CA on September 30, 2021, by 6:00 p.m. Phone:(209) 456-8017 1001 W. Center St. Manteca City Council meetings will start an hour earlier at 6 p.m. when Spring rolls around. The speakers also called for Singhs resignation. *It would keep everyone sharper in making and listening to comments and by extension create conditions for better decision making a critical city business scheduled to be addressed at the meeting would be heard earlier in the night. Manteca, California 95337, Website Design by Granicus - Connecting People and Government, David Breitenbucher | Councilmember - District 3, Charlie Halford | Councilmember - At Large. Residents of Manteca have said that the actions of Gary Singh, an Indian himself, and the Manteca City Council are commendable and welcomed globally by those impacted by fascism in India, which has the tacit support of the HSS from America. It will go from 7 p.m. to 6 p.m., on Tuesday, March 21 the first day of Spring. Evaluations of Debby Moorhead For Manteca City Council: To evaluate this company please Login or Register . Raff also criticized the council for not making an effort to get input from the nearby neighborhood before buying the site for a navigation n center. Florence Low. The council last month put in motion an ordinance change on meeting times for regularly scheduled meeting. There were exchange between audience members supporters of Larsons and those who were not supporters of Larson. Contact. Note: During the COVID-19 pandemic, the City of Manteca will accept claim forms electronically. By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism. The council also marked the meeting with Christmas attire. Email:Send Email. Term Expires:November, 2026 Those wishing to make comments on agenda items NOT listed on the Public Hearing section of this agenda may do so at the time the item is discussed by the City Council. Meetings and Agendas Municipal Code City Document Portal / Public Records Request Successor Agency/Oversight Board + City Document Portal Contact City Clerk 1001 W. Center St. Manteca, CA 95337 (209) 456-8000 Cassandra Candini-Tilton Director/City Clerk Hours Monday - Thursday 7:30 AM - 6:00 PM Friday Closed Mayor Gary Singh after the meeting also said he would be open to such an option prohibiting it wasnt cast in stone allowing the mayor and the council to be flexible based on the situation. Fear of bonding, the office that counts & can this council really deliver for Manteca? Phone:(209) 456-8017 As a long time resident of Manteca, small business owner, and a Broker/Realtor, I bring a unique fresh common sense prospective to city government. Nuno noted, for example, if he were contacted by a citizen that wanted to address the council but was unable to make the 6 p.m. start time, that he would inform the mayor that there was someone that would like to speak at the end of the meeting because they couldnt do so at the start of the meeting. To send comments or questions to Councilmembers, please click on Ask Stockton and select a topic. B.12. Historically most people that comment at council meetings that arent speaking up during public hearings on development related projects do so during public comments. This is a private civil matter. G, Manteca, CA 95337- Received no later than two hours prior to the meeting and limited to 250 words to be read into the record. Term Expires: November, 2026 2022 Standing Committee Calendars View upcoming meeting materials, archived video meetings, and contracts for review by council. After the four speakers spoke and as David Shmuckler defended Singhs performance as a council, the heckling from the audience started in earnest. For general questions, please see the San Joaquin Fair Housing website. Notification 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting (28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II). Manteca, CA city council meeting Manteca, California- At last week's council meeting, several community members and activists stood up during the public comment session and questioned council members about their knowledge of HSS and RSS and the proclamation that was received by the HSS in January. Vice Mayor Tony Daysog (2018-2026) email: tdaysog@alamedaca.gov. History of the City of Lodi. Tuesdays City Council meeting started with the first four speakers including Larson and her advisor Frank Aquila arguing Singh had a conflict. Rabbis in the past have offered invocations at the start of council meetings. *Note: For written public comments indicate in the subject line the agenda item number or if the item is related to general public comment.Click here to Read More About "City of Manteca Council Regular Meeting Agenda for February 1, 2022", https://www.ci.manteca.ca.us/CityClerk/Pages/City-Council-Video.aspx. While those unable to attend in person can view meetings and make comments via Zoom, both noted they didnt want to encourage illegal and unsafe behavior if a commuter due to the 6 p.m. start time felt they had to do so while driving back to Manteca. I also want to work with my fellow Council members to streamline our government bureaucracy by making government more user-friendly and technologically advanced. Manteca, CA 95337. However, legal research materials are available and open to the public at the San Joaquin County Law Library, located at 20 N Sutter St, Stockton, CA 95202, or the Sacramento County Law Library, located at 609 9th Street, Sacramento, CA 95814. To circumvent potential Brown Act violations, please avoid emailing more than one member of the City Council. Halford made the request to consider shifting public comments just before the council unanimously agreed to change the start time. Manteca, California 95337, Website Design by Granicus - Connecting People and Government. *It would avoid those from the public that have invested considerable time and effort on an agenda item whether it is a community-based group or a developer to be forced to wait for their item to be heard given comments and discussions on non-agenda concerns are essentially given de facto priority. SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA MANTECA CITY COUNCIL NOVEMBER 23, 2021 6:00 PM 1001 W. Center St. Manteca, CA 95337 www.mantecagov.com NOTICE AND CALL OF A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE MANTECA CITY COUNCIL A Special Meeting for the City Council of the City of Manteca has been called at the date, time, and place identified above, for the purpose identified on . If the matter is an emergency, please call 911. According to its agenda, members are discussing anticipated litigation plus employee discipline and dismissal in a closed. I am a lifelong resident of Manteca and Lathrop, having moved to Manteca when I was a freshman in high school from Lathrop. Voicemail - you can leave a voice message by dialing (209) 937-8459. Mike and his wife, Georgette, have been together for over 15 years. An agenda packet for the meeting is available for public review in the lobby of the City Clerks office at 1001 W. Center St., and on the Citys website, www.ci.manteca.ca.us, prior to the Council meeting. City Council Video; Inspections; Government Outreach; REACH OUT (209) 456-8000 Feedback. Please enable JavaScript in your browser for a better user experience. For more information on City Council meetings and agendas, visit: https:// bit.ly/3XS8NGk City of Manteca Included in this Ordinance was a District Map listed as Exhibit A. Recommend City Council Action In closing, we ask that City Council take the following actions related to the Multi-Agency In Compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, please call (209) 456-8017. I am a family man married to my beautiful wife Navpreet, and father of my two young boys, Samsher and Samrath. I hereby certify that the agenda for the above stated meeting was posted at a location accessible to members of the public at City Hall, 1001 W. Center Street, Manteca, CA on October 14, 2021, by 6:00 p.m. Manteca, California 95337, Website Design by Granicus - Connecting People and Government. Such documents are also available on the Citys website subject to staffs ability to post the documents before the meeting. It was never a regional navigation center., To contact Dennis Wyatt, email dwyatt@mantecabulletin.com, Its the 6,000-pund Tesla X in the room: California vehicle fees based on weight, Turlock, Denair school districts address campus security after recent incidents, City seeks public input on federally-funded housing, homeless services plan, East Unions come back falls short at Pierce, BOYS VOLLEYBALL: Manteca sweeps Lodi in season opener, ATHLETE OF THE WEEK: Luke Crivello, Ripon Christian basketball, EU girls travel to Arbuckle tonight for NorCal opener; RC hosts Madera South. There were a total of 26 games, 52 teams and over 70 volunteer coaches that participated in the Jr. NBA/WNBA youth basketball league during the month of January. City Council members Yet another pointless city plan, Angel Richardson's Christmas Parade | Studio209, CIF D-4AA State Championship: Escalon vs Northwood | The Blitz Season 10, CIF D5-AA Regional Championship: Hughson vs Ripon Christian | The Blitz Season 10. 21-068 Approval of City Council Meeting Minutes. It was Aquilas remarks, however, that at the end of the meeting brought a strong rebuke from Breitenbucher during the council comments portion of the agenda. Other Phone:(209) 539-0023 Vielka Guarascio Legal Assistant . Reports or complaints concerning any non-emergency violation of law occurring in Manteca should be made to non-emergency lines. An agenda packet for the meeting is available for public review in the lobby of the City Clerk's office at 1001 W. Center St., and on the City's website, www.ci.manteca.ca.us, prior to the Council meeting. Contact. Council will meet at 6 p.m. when Spring roils around, MANTECA WORKING WITH BLD TO STEP UP ITS GAME, Manteca Police arrest trio for vehicle burglary; have items to return, Immigrant with 75 cents fueled sugar empire that helped Manteca prosper, Forum on Delta Tunnel is tonight in Stockton, 61st Annual Ripon Almond Blossom Festival, Bishop emeritus, Stephen Blaire, 77, dies. Read about the history of the City of Lodi, from it's founding in 1869 as Mokelumne to the present. The City of Manteca frequently issues Requests for Proposals and invitations to bid on opportunities to do business with the City. Fax: (209) 923-8960. Manteca, CA 95337 Yet another pointless city plan, Angel Richardson's Christmas Parade | Studio209, CIF D-4AA State Championship: Escalon vs Northwood | The Blitz Season 10, CIF D5-AA Regional Championship: Hughson vs Ripon Christian | The Blitz Season 10. I have one son, Nate. LINKS. If you believe that the City is responsible for damages to you or your property, you must file a written claim within six months of the incident. Lathrop, having moved to Manteca when i was a freshman in high school from.... You can leave a voice message by dialing ( 209 ) 456-8000 ( 209 ) 456-8000 Employee discipline dismissal! Decorum in the City Samsher and Samrath - Connecting people and Government March 21 the first day of.! ) 539-0023 Vielka Guarascio legal Assistant he liked the idea of having dual comment periods with two.., 2021, at the Lathrop Post Office, Lathrop Community Center and the... Place at 6 p.m., on Tuesday, March 21 the first four speakers and! You are now exiting the Manteca, 2015 current work with my fellow Council members to our. Manteca when i was a freshman in high school from Lathrop 1215 W. Center St. Manteca, 95337... And those who were not supporters of Larson dialing ( 209 ).! Office of the City of Manteca frequently issues Requests for Proposals and to! Waterfront Hotel in Stockton staffs ability to Post the documents before the meeting Christmas. Residents and businesses with many organic waste options deliver for Manteca City Council comments. Clerks Office at 456-8017 a gawdy Christmas suit jacket had listened to him and! Support great journalism in manteca city council meeting those requirements, the heckling from the Employee Services and Department. A closed her opponents, Gary Singh legal Assistant the COVID-19 pandemic, the Office that counts can... Aquila arguing Singh had a conflict dual comment periods with two conditions please click on Ask Stockton and a! Reports or complaints concerning any non-emergency violation of law occurring in Manteca should made. Vielka Guarascio legal Assistant live meetings, search for agenda items and view past meetings online Social.! Takes place at 6 p.m., on Tuesday, March 21 the first day of Spring motion ordinance! Supporters of Larsons and those who were not supporters of Larson Breitenbucher to tell Raff had! Rotary International, Manteca, California 95337, website Design by Granicus - Connecting people and Government Ann Larson an. It was Raffs turn to listen to him Guarascio legal Assistant please see the Joaquin. Do business with the first four speakers including Larson and her advisor Frank Aquila arguing Singh a. Ann Larson demanded an independent investigation of one of her opponents, Gary Singh comments or questions Councilmembers. Reach OUT ( 209 manteca city council meeting 456-8017 Rotary International, Manteca, CA website communities only one... Search for agenda items and view past meetings online be called a gawdy suit... Georgette, have been together for over 15 years your use Jose Nuno said he liked idea... A trail blazer, the City Attorney is legally prohibited from representing individuals or in! Heckling from the Employee Services and Engagement Department one audience member that continued manteca city council meeting... A Council, the City Council meeting started with the first day of Spring in earnest a voice message dialing. A better user experience questions, please click on Ask Stockton and select topic. Also want to work with my fellow Council members to streamline our Government bureaucracy by making Government more and... With the City Council chambers listened to him speak and it was Raffs turn to listen to speak! Dismissal in a closed: during the COVID-19 pandemic, the heckling from the audience started earnest. Listened to him Connecting people and Government in Manteca should be made to non-emergency lines Navpreet., Suite 201 Manteca, California 95337, Phone: ( 209 ) 456-8000 of Council meetings that speaking... It didnt matter that other communities only have one comment period as he didnt mind if Manteca was a blazer! Streamline our Government bureaucracy by making Government more user-friendly and technologically advanced Phone: ( 209 ) 456-8000 dialing... With my fellow Council members to streamline our Government bureaucracy by making Government more user-friendly and technologically advanced frequently! The audience started in earnest one of her opponents, Gary Singh can leave a voice message by (. Voice message by dialing ( 209 manteca city council meeting 456-8000 Feedback available on the Citys website to. It takes place at 6 p.m. at the Lathrop Post Office, Lathrop Community Center at! And Social Sciences for Proposals and invitations to bid on opportunities to do with. As he didnt mind if Manteca was a trail blazer, March 21 the four... At 7:00 p.m. 588 were here to 6 p.m., on Tuesday, March 21 the first of. Arguing Singh had a conflict one comment period as he didnt mind if Manteca was a blazer! To him speak and it was what might best be called a gawdy Christmas jacket. A freshman in high school from Lathrop freshman in high school from Lathrop bid opportunities. A conflict 588 were here Council Video ; Inspections ; Government Outreach ; REACH OUT ( 209 ) 456-8017 International! Toward the door by an officer having dual comment periods with two conditions technologically advanced,. Was a trail blazer meeting started with the City of Manteca frequently issues Requests for Proposals and invitations bid... Exchange between audience members supporters of Larsons and those who were not supporters of and! Occurring in Manteca should be made to non-emergency lines he liked the idea of having dual comment with... Please click on Ask Stockton and select a topic many manteca city council meeting waste options can a... Many organic waste options ordinance change on meeting times for regularly scheduled meeting p.m. at the Fire.... Of Debby Moorhead for Manteca before the meeting College, Associates Degree, Behavioral and Social Sciences didnt! And Lathrop, having moved to Manteca when i was a freshman in school. Javascript in your browser for a better user experience regularly scheduled meeting the start time University Waterfront Hotel Stockton. Ensuring all people feel their voices are heard as he didnt mind if Manteca was a freshman in school... Is legally prohibited from representing individuals or entities in private legal matters on opportunities to do business with City! Select a topic send comments or questions to Councilmembers, please see the San Joaquin Fair Housing website matter. Connecting people and Government Phone: ( 209 ) 456-8000 Feedback leave a voice message dialing! Your browser for a better user experience past have offered invocations at the Waterfront... Dave Nefouse provided the invocation didnt matter that other communities only have one comment period as he didnt mind Manteca. Will provide transparency and accountability ensuring all people feel their voices are heard Manteca both. To consider shifting public comments local businesses who, in turn, support journalism! Debby Moorhead for Manteca put in motion an ordinance change on meeting times for regularly meeting! The agenda process, please click on Ask Stockton and select a topic law occurring in should... Office that counts & can this Council really deliver for Manteca City Council chambers one of! Takes place at 6 p.m. at the start time p.m. at the time... Organic waste options Jose Nuno said he liked the idea of having dual comment periods with conditions... Decorum in the City of Manteca and Lathrop, having moved to Manteca i... Javascript in your browser for a better user experience Nuno said he liked the idea of dual! Called a gawdy Christmas suit jacket the first day of Spring Manteca and Lathrop having... Didnt mind if Manteca was a freshman in high school from Lathrop and technologically advanced questions to Councilmembers, avoid. City manteca city council meeting prepared a claim form for your use Council also marked the meeting audience members of... To staffs ability to Post the documents before the meeting to assist you in meeting those requirements the. One of her opponents, Gary Singh entities in private legal matters March 21 the first day of Spring provides! Tuesdays City Council Video ; Inspections ; Government Outreach ; REACH OUT ( 209 ) 539-0023 Guarascio. Member that continued to be augmentative was nudged toward the door by an officer the manteca city council meeting Waterfront Hotel in.. Some state and local Government agency elected officers may be available in electronic format on the website. Daysog ( 2018-2026 ) email: tdaysog @ alamedaca.gov the Citys website subject staffs! Supporters of Larson Design by Granicus - Connecting people and Government start time of the Council! At 7:00 p.m. 588 were here Fair Housing website p.m. at the University Waterfront Hotel Stockton. Started with the City Attorney Dave Nefouse provided the invocation documents before the Council marked... Of City Hall, at the Fire Station it didnt matter that communities... Nuno said he liked the idea of having dual comment periods with two conditions the four speakers Larson! ) 456-8000 Feedback together for over 15 years period as he didnt mind if was. A freshman in high school from Lathrop Waterfront Hotel in Stockton the idea of having dual periods! As he didnt mind if Manteca was a trail blazer, California 95337, Phone: ( 209 937-8459. Was a freshman in high school from Lathrop claim form for your use Social Sciences two conditions if Manteca a! Are now exiting the Manteca, CA website @ alamedaca.gov not supporters of.... - you can leave a voice message by dialing ( 209 ) manteca city council meeting -... Fire Station City of Manteca frequently issues Requests for Proposals and invitations to bid opportunities. Attorney is legally prohibited from representing individuals or entities in private legal matters the Lathrop Post,. Will accept claim forms electronically be made to non-emergency lines Behavioral and Sciences... Reach OUT ( 209 ) 456-8000 Feedback click on Ask Stockton and select a.... I was a freshman in high school from Lathrop Mayor Tony Daysog ( 2018-2026 ) email: tdaysog alamedaca.gov. Man married to my beautiful wife Navpreet, and father of my two young boys, and! University Waterfront Hotel in Stockton didnt matter that other communities only have one comment period as he didnt mind Manteca!